Esprit critique
← All fallacies
fallacy · Generalisation

No true Scotsman

Aucun vrai Écossais

Faced with a counterexample, changing the definition of a group after the fact to exclude it and protect a generalisation.

Argument diagram

All Xs are P.

Here is an X that is not P.

Then it isn’t a true X.

Why the argument is invalid

The generalisation becomes irrefutable: every counterexample is dismissed by definition. It then says nothing about the world; it is a mere tautology.

In practice

Example

“No Scotsman puts sugar on his porridge.” — “My Scottish uncle does.” — “Then he’s not a true Scotsman.”

Defending yourself

How to respond

Ask for a definition of the group fixed before the cases are examined: “What makes someone a true X, regardless of this example?”

Don’t confuse

Moving the goalposts

The no true Scotsman move redefines a group to dismiss a counterexample; moving the goalposts changes the standard of proof demanded.

Going further

Source

Antony Flew, “Thinking About Thinking” (1975).

Practise

In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.

Open the interactive entry