Appeal to tradition
Argumentum ad antiquitatem, Appel à la tradition
Justifying a practice or an idea by its age.
The essentials
Argument diagram
We have always done X.
So X is good.
Why the argument is invalid
The longevity of a practice proves neither its effectiveness nor its legitimacy: bloodletting was practised by doctors for more than two thousand years. A tradition can be justified, but for reasons other than its age. The reverse, the appeal to novelty (“it’s recent, so it’s better”), is just as fallacious.
In practice
Example
“We have always run the exam this way, there is no reason to change.”
Famous case
Bloodletting was practised in medicine for more than two millennia. In December 1799, George Washington, suffering from a severe throat infection, was bled four times in about twelve hours. Estimates of the volume taken range from 2.4 to 3.7 litres, 40% or more of his blood. He died that same evening.
Defending yourself
How to respond
Ask what reasons, apart from age, justify the practice.
Don’t confuse
Not to be confused with: Appeal to nature
The appeal to tradition invokes the age of a practice; the appeal to nature, its natural character.
Going further
Source
Jeremy Bentham, “The Book of Fallacies” (1824), Part I, chapter 2: “The Wisdom of our Ancestors, or Chinese Argument”.
Practise
In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.