Esprit critique
← All fallacies
fallacy · Causation

Texas sharpshooter fallacy

Sophisme du tireur d'élite

Spotting a cluster in random data after the fact and presenting it as significant, while ignoring the data that do not fit it.

Argument diagram

First you shoot, then you draw the target around the bullet holes.

Why the argument is invalid

Chance naturally produces clusters. A hypothesis formed after seeing the data always fits them; it must be tested on new data to count as proof.

In practice

Example

A farmer fires at random at a barn, then draws targets around the tightest cluster of holes to pass himself off as a sharpshooter.

Defending yourself

How to respond

State the hypothesis before examining the data. Ask how many comparisons were made to find this result.

Don’t confuse

Apophenia (bias)

The Texas sharpshooter fallacy turns a pattern spotted after the fact into an argument; apophenia is the spontaneous tendency to perceive patterns.

Going further

Source

Public health services know the difficulty with cancer clusters: cases are noticed first, then the cluster’s boundary is drawn around them (Connecticut Department of Public Health, technical brief “Cancer Clusters”).

Practise

In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.

Open the interactive entry