Loaded question
Complex question, Plurium interrogationum, Question piège
Asking a question that contains an unestablished presupposition, so that any direct answer seems to validate it.
The essentials
Argument diagram
Question that presupposes P.
Any “yes” or “no” answer validates P.
Why the argument is invalid
The question actually contains two: one (the presupposition) has never been asked or proven. Answering directly amounts to accepting it implicitly.
In practice
Example
“Have you stopped cheating in exams?” Yes or no, the answer admits to having cheated.
Defending yourself
How to respond
Reject the presupposition before answering: “Your question assumes that…, which has not been established.”
Don’t confuse
Not to be confused with: Begging the question
The loaded question slips a presupposition into a question; begging the question slips the conclusion into the premises of an argument.
Going further
Source
Described by Aristotle in the Sophistical Refutations (chapters 4 and 5): making several questions into one, to which a single answer is expected.
See also
Practise
In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.