Nirvana fallacy
Perfect solution fallacy, Sophisme du nirvana
Rejecting a realistic solution because it is not perfect, by comparing it with an ideal solution that does not exist.
The essentials
Argument diagram
Solution S does not fully solve the problem.
So S must be rejected.
Why the argument is invalid
The right comparison sets the options actually available against each other, including doing nothing. An imperfect measure can be far better than no measure.
In practice
Example
“Seat belts don’t save everyone in accidents; what’s the point of making them compulsory?”
Defending yourself
How to respond
Compare the proposed option with the real alternative, not with an ideal: “Is it better than what would happen without it?”
Don’t confuse
Not to be confused with: False dilemma
The false dilemma ignores options that exist; the nirvana fallacy compares a real option with an ideal option that does not exist.
Going further
Source
The economist Harold Demsetz (1969) criticises the “nirvana approach”, which compares a real situation with an unattainable ideal rather than with other feasible solutions.
Practise
In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.