Genetic fallacy
Sophisme génétique
Judging an idea true or false, good or bad, by its origin rather than its merits.
The essentials
Argument diagram
P comes from source S.
So P is false (or true).
Why the argument is invalid
The origin of an idea can explain why we believe it, but it does not determine its truth. An idea born in bad conditions can be right, and vice versa. The personal attack is a particular case.
In practice
Example
“This method was invented by a private company to sell its products: it can’t be reliable.”
Famous case
August Kekulé said he found the ring structure of benzene (1865) by dreaming of a snake biting its own tail. This dreamlike origin takes nothing away from the validity of the structure, established by other means.
Defending yourself
How to respond
Separate the history of an idea from its justification: “Its origin doesn’t tell us whether it is true. What lets us judge it today?”
Don’t confuse
Not to be confused with: Personal attack
The personal attack targets the person who defends an idea; the genetic fallacy, the historical origin of that idea.
Going further
Source
Hans Reichenbach (1938) distinguishes the context of discovery of an idea from its context of justification.
Practise
In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.