Esprit critique
← All fallacies
fallacy · False comparison

False equivalence

False balance, Fausse équivalence

Presenting two things as equivalent because they share a trait, when they differ greatly in seriousness, scale or soundness.

Argument diagram

A and B have something in common.

So A and B are equal.

Why the argument is invalid

The common point is real, but secondary: it masks a difference of scale or of kind. Presenting two positions as equally well founded, when the evidence leans clearly to one side, is a common form of it.

In practice

Example

“He forgot to return a library book, she embezzled public money: both broke the rules, neither is any better than the other.”

Famous case

In 2011, a report commissioned by the BBC Trust from the geneticist Steve Jones criticised the BBC for giving excessive attention to fringe opinions in its science coverage, notably on climate, in the name of an overly rigid application of impartiality.

Defending yourself

How to respond

Compare scale and evidence, not just category: “Are the two comparable in seriousness, frequency, soundness?”

Don’t confuse

Middle ground fallacy

The middle ground fallacy concludes that the truth lies between two positions; false equivalence asserts that two positions or two facts are equal.

Going further

Source

Studied in research on the media coverage of science under the name “false balance”. Maxwell and Jules Boykoff, “Balance as bias” (Global Environmental Change, 2004): in the US prestige press from 1988 to 2002, the pursuit of balance drew popular discourse away from the scientific consensus on global warming.

Practise

In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.

Open the interactive entry