Esprit critique
← All fallacies
fallacy · Generalisation

Composition and division

Fallacy of composition, Fallacy of division, Composition et division

Attributing to a whole the properties of its parts (composition), or to the parts the properties of the whole (division).

Argument diagram

Every part of X has P.

So X has P. (Or the reverse.)

Why the argument is invalid

A whole can have properties that its parts do not (emergent properties), and vice versa. A team of good players can be a bad team.

In practice

Example

Composition: “Every atom is invisible, so this wall is invisible.” Division: “This university is prestigious, so each of its students is brilliant.”

Defending yourself

How to respond

Ask whether the property depends on how the whole is organised, or only on each element taken separately.

Don’t confuse

Equivocation

Composition transfers a property from the parts to the whole; equivocation plays on two senses of the same word.

Going further

Source

Described by Aristotle in the Sophistical Refutations (chapter 4, among the fallacies dependent on language). In economics, the “paradox of thrift”, popularised by Keynes, is a classic example.

Practise

In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.

Open the interactive entry