Regression fallacy
Neglect of regression to the mean, Négligence de la régression vers la moyenne
Attributing a specific cause to a return towards normal that is simply explained by statistical variability.
The essentials
Mechanism
An extreme result is often partly due to chance. The next measurement therefore tends to be closer to the average. Since we spontaneously look for causes, we attribute this return to whatever happened between the two measurements.
In practice
Example
An athlete makes the cover of a magazine after an exceptional season, then their results drop. People speak of the “cover curse”, when an exceptional season is rarely followed by another.
Famous case
Daniel Kahneman tells how an Israeli Air Force instructor claimed that praise made trainee pilots perform worse and that reprimands made them perform better. It was regression to the mean: after an exceptional flight, the next one is on average worse, whatever the instructor’s reaction.
Defending yourself
How to protect yourself
Before attributing an improvement or a decline to an intervention, ask whether the starting point was extreme. Compare with a control group that did not receive the intervention.
Don’t confuse
Not to be confused with: Post hoc ergo propter hoc (fallacy)
Post hoc attributes an effect to whatever precedes it; regression to the mean explains why that attribution so often misleads after an extreme result.
Going further
Source
Francis Galton (1886), on the height of the children of very tall or very short parents.
Practise
In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.