Motivated reasoning
Identity-protective cognition, Raisonnement motivé
Evaluating arguments and data so as to reach the conclusion one wants, rather than the one they support.
The essentials
Mechanism
When a conclusion matters to us (identity, interest, belonging), we examine what supports it leniently and what contradicts it severely. The reasoning remains rigorous in appearance: it is the level of demand that changes depending on the conclusion.
In practice
Example
A smoker finds studies on the harms of tobacco unconvincing, but finds an article claiming that pollution is the real cause of lung cancer solid.
Famous case
Kahan, Peters, Dawson and Slovic (2017): the participants most comfortable with numbers interpret a table of results on a skin-rash cream better. When the same figures concern a ban on carrying guns, their answers polarise according to their political views, and the gap is largest among the most numerate.
Defending yourself
How to protect yourself
Apply the same level of scrutiny to arguments whatever their conclusion. Ask: would I judge this study the same way if it reached the opposite result?
Don’t confuse
Not to be confused with: Confirmation bias
Confirmation bias can be involuntary and apply to any hypothesis; motivated reasoning is driven by the desire to reach a conclusion that matters to us.
Going further
Source
Ziva Kunda (1990), “The case for motivated reasoning”. Hastorf and Cantril (1954), “They saw a game”: after a rough match between Princeton and Dartmouth, 86% of Princeton students blame Dartmouth for starting the rough play, against 36% of Dartmouth students.
Practise
In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.