Belief bias
Biais de croyance
Judging the validity of an argument by how plausible its conclusion is, not by its logical structure.
The essentials
Mechanism
Evaluating the form of an argument takes an effort of abstraction. So we substitute an easier question for “does the conclusion follow from the premises?”: “is the conclusion true?”
In practice
Example
“All roses are flowers. Some flowers fade quickly. Therefore some roses fade quickly.” Most people judge this argument valid, because its conclusion is plausible. Yet it does not follow from the premises: the flowers that fade quickly could all be tulips.
Defending yourself
How to protect yourself
Separate two questions: are the premises true? Does the conclusion follow from them? Replace the terms with letters (A, B, C) to judge the form.
Don’t confuse
Not to be confused with: Fallacy fallacy (fallacy)
Belief bias judges an argument valid or not according to whether its conclusion seems true; the fallacy fallacy judges a conclusion false because the argument defending it is bad.
Going further
Source
Evans, Barston and Pollard (1983). Invalid syllogisms with a believable conclusion are accepted far more often than valid syllogisms with an unbelievable conclusion.
Practise
In the app, each entry offers ways to practise recognising the concept. No sign-up: your progress stays on your device.